Selected Handgun Detail

Smith & Wesson
Model 686P
Smith & Wesson Revolver 686P .357 Mag Variant-4
Scale To:
Gun Dimensions Width:No Data
Length:10.375-in Height:No Data
Barrel:5-in Weight:40.5-oz
Variant 4 of 5
Gun Rankings
  • Power Factor (158 grain bullet)202872
  • Recoil Factor (158 grain bullet)9.16 ft-lb
  • Total Capacity7 rounds
  • ConcealabilityPoor
  • Defense Factor64%
Gun Specifications
Type:Revolver
Caliber:.357 Mag
Action:revolving chamber
Trigger:double-action (DA/SA)
Safety:
Cylinder:7-round
Frame:stainless steel
Grip:Ahrens wood cocobolo
Sights:fiber-optic front, adj. V-notch rear
Notes:Stocking Dealer Special
Manufacturer
Smith & Wesson
More Info
About the Gun

This was a limited run Model 686P variant with a rare half lug 5" barrel, Hi-Viz front sight, and wood stocks.

Production

Production of this specific model occurred between 2004 and 2006 as a limited run for a stocking dealer special. Exact dates within this range may vary based on individual unit serialization and distribution.

Market value
Last updated: 7/9/2025

The MSRP for this gun is approximately $1,200 for a new unit. The market value for a used one in 95% condition is around $900-$1,000, based on recent 2025 sales data.

Cartridge Specifications
Cartridge: .357 Magnum
Alias: .357 Smith & Wesson Magnum
More Info
Ballistics for This Gun
Selected Bullet Mass:158 grains
MV:1284 ft/sec ME:579 ft-lbs
Analysis

This .357 Magnum revolver exemplifies precision engineering with a robust stainless steel frame that ensures durability under heavy use. Its accuracy is commendable, delivering tight groupings at moderate ranges, making it a solid choice for both target shooting and personal defense. The ergonomics are well-considered, with a grip that accommodates a variety of hand sizes, promoting a secure hold during extended sessions. Reliability is a key asset, as it consistently performs across diverse conditions with proper care. However, maintenance can be demanding, requiring regular attention to prevent wear on critical components. Parts availability may pose challenges for some users, particularly for older variants. The trigger pull is smooth in double-action mode, though it might feel heavy for beginners. Felt recoil is noticeable with full-power loads, potentially affecting shooters unaccustomed to magnum calibers, but it remains manageable with practice.

User Rating
1 User Ratings
1 User Comments
User Comments

5 of 5 Stars
686 P
By Dano on 06 Aug 2022
Very accurate with moderate recoil .