Selected Handgun Detail

Manufacturer
	Smith & Wesson More Info

About the Gun

Third generation single-stack double-action semi-automatic pistol, stainless steel construction. Compact variant of the full-side model 4506. Features a bobbed hammer.

Production

Production of this model occurred between 1990 and 1999.

Market value

Used market value for this gun in 95% condition is approximately $600-$700.

Cartridge Specifications
Cartridge:	.45 Automatic
Alias:	.45 Automatic Colt Pistol (ACP)
More Info

Analysis

The Smith & Wesson Model 4516 stands out in the compact .45 ACP market for its robust all-steel build, delivering excellent recoil management and inherent accuracy that many owners describe as exceptional—even from the shorter barrel—once shooters adapt to the double-action/single-action trigger (typically long and heavy in DA with some creep in SA). User reports consistently highlight reliable function across well-maintained examples, particularly the later dash variants, with the pistol often praised for eating a broad spectrum of ammunition without hiccups. The model's dash progression reflects iterative factory refinements: the no-dash originals occasionally faced feeding challenges linked to early tolerances and magazine geometry, addressed in the -1 through internal tweaks and model-specific magazines (often marked for exclusive use), and further optimized in the -2 with a dual recoil spring system on a narrower guide rod for smoother cycling and broader compatibility. Owners frequently call the -2 the sweet spot for consistency. While the heft enhances control and reduces felt recoil compared to lighter polymer competitors, it remains a drawback for all-day concealed carry in today's market favoring slimmer, lighter options. Still, for those valuing traditional duty-grade durability, shootability, and a classic third-gen feel, the 4516 holds strong appeal as a capable, long-lasting compact .45.